Niall Seewang

AUSTRALIA


Joined April 21st 2008

Number of Posts:
6

Number of Comments:
0

Karma:
7



Blogs

Niall Seewang's Blogs

609 Vote(s)
8 Comment(s)
6 Post(s)

I mentor these bloggers

Learn more about the Orble Mentoring Program.


I do not mentor any bloggers.

Friends

I have no friends :(

Recent Posts

THIS weekend’s Tribute Game at the MCG between Victoria and a ‘Dream Team’ - made up of the other 7 states and territories - has been organised to celebrate the game’s 150th year.

It will be a contest between the best 44 football players in the country (bar a few injured stars) at the biggest, most famous ground in the land.

Why, then, is there so little interest?

Is it because other 7 states and territories are insulted because they’ve been shoved together in a manufactured ‘Dream Team’ to play as one against the Vics?

Almost certainly. While games between different states (especially South Australia v Victoria) - back when state of origin was a regular fixture - were often passion-fuelled gladitorial contests, one can only imagine it will be difficult for the Dream Team to muster similar enthusiasm.

Is it because a lot of AFL supporters have grown up supporting their own club, and put their club above all?

Probably. As The Age’s Greg Baum so eloquently put it: “A club provides its fans with important links, to a place, to the past, with all its resonances, and to each other. It provides a sense of tribalism, of belonging, of righteous struggle — week by week, season by season, decade by decade — in which no game stands alone, but is a step one way or the other in that ceaseless and unifying struggle.

The Tribute Game, by definition, sits outside this dynamic. It is a one-off, an exhibition, between two representative teams, one rarely seen, the other made up.”

Is it because AFL supporters are worried their teams’ stars might get injured?

You bet. Amongst the excitement of watching a (most likely) entertaining contest, dread will be an underlying feeling amongst all supporters watching their stars crash and bash their way through the exhibition game.

Brisbane supporters will wince every time Victorian skipper Jonathon Brown smashes through a pack. Fremantle followers will cross their fingers when their only truly gun, Mathew Pavlich, flies for a mark and those with Blue and White running through their veins will feel every one of Jimmy Bartel’s bumps and tackles.

The AFL has been doing their utmost to drum up interest in the game, with advertising across all mediums at saturation point.

So far, an estimated 30,000 tickets have been sold, hardly an indication of frenzied support. With good weather, the game could attract a crowd of more than 70,000, still less than what the AFL would want.

But then again, it is Melbourne we’re talking about, a city that would turn out in force to watch a yabbie race if there was nothing else on.

Seeing as it’s the only game on for the weekend, I’m expecting (barring foul weather) a crowd in the vicinity of 75,000.

Just don’t expect to see a contest like this again anytime soon.
88
Vote
   


Ray Chamberlain - hang your head

April 28th 2008 12:57
UMPIRES have the most thankless job in the AFL. They are verbally abused, ridiculed and torn to shreds by AFL players, supporters and probably even coaches (under their breath of course, so as to not be fined).

The best compliment umpires can receive is someone telling them they hadn’t noticed them on the field.

Wow, what a nice feeling that must be.

They are employed by the AFL and do their best to make sure games run as smoothly as possible, within the rules. Of course, they make mistakes, but so does everyone in their chosen professions.

Players, we all know, make errors all the time. They miss targets by hand and foot, they drop marks they should take, they make errors of judgment and take the wrong options.

Coaches make mistakes, too, and their blues are pored over by analysts, commentators and board members. Coaches are always a few bad defeats away from becoming ‘this close’ to getting the sack.

That’s just the way it is.

Umpires, though, are the most reviled creatures in the AFL but more often than not, the criticism they cop isn’t warranted.

But sometimes, an umpire makes an error so awful, so baffling and so frustrating that it makes your blood boil.

On Saturday, Ray Chamberlain got noticed in a big way.

Chamberlain penalised Carlton’s Jarrad Waite for punching the ball into the crowd after it had been kicked through for a goal by Bernie Vince.

Chamberlain - in a decision fuelled by ego and a desire to be part of the action - judged the Carlton defender to have caused a delay in the play. The ball was then given to Richard Douglas at the top of the goal square for another shot at close range.

Bang. Game over.

At the time, Carlton was a couple of goals behind and would’ve needed all the time they could to claw their way back into the contest. Why then, would Waite deliberately waste time?

It was one of the most petulant and ridiculous displays of over-officiating I can remember and it cost the Blues dearly.

Last week, umpire Damien Sully paid for his skill error after his shocking centre bounce in the closing stages of the Collingwood-North Melbourne clash.

Sully’s bounce gifted North Melbourne an entry into their 50-metre area, where rookie Ed Lower snapped a goal, putting North Melbourne in front by eight points, a lead they held onto.

Amid much outcry, especially from the Collingwood faithful, Sully was dropped to the VFL for what AFL umpires director Jeff Gieschen said was a series of bad bounces.

That’s fair enough. If a footballer performs basic skills badly repeatedly, they are dropped to the reserves.

I doubt many would have a problem with Silly’s demotion, probably not even the man himself.

Chamberlain’s case is different altogether. One can only hope Gieschen will dish out the same medicine to Chamberlain, who, in one arrogant action, gave every AFL fan a valid reason to bemoan the men in white.
106
Vote
   


THE Melbourne Football Club is in disarray. 0 wins, 5 big losses, no real positives in sight.

But there is something that can be done as early as this week to prepare the Dees for a brighter future - naming the right captain to take over from the injured David Neitz.

The Dees will go one of three directions on this issue - name an older player as a short-term fix, go down the co-captaincy route or bank on a youngster to drive their fortunes upwards.

Who, then, are the major contenders through my eyes?

The older brigade:


James McDonald
'Junior' as he is known is about as blue-collar as it gets. Dedicated, respected, selfless and consistent on the football field. One of the major contenders if the Dees opt for someone from the older generation.

Brad Green
Green has responded magnificently since being dumped from the leadership group at the start of the year. Will the fact he isn't in the group go against him though?

Cameron Bruce
Has bounced back from an appalling 2007 and is one of Melbourne's true guns when fit and firing. Commands respect on the field, but what about off it?

Young guns:

Brock McLean

Anointed the future captain in waiting even as far back as 2006 but off-field indiscretions during the pre-season may hurt his chances. Speaks his mind. Is respected for his hardness on the field and one would think will become captain of the side at some stage.

Nathan Jones
Another young man who hasn't put a foot wrong on or off the field. Growing in stature around the club and on the field. But would the captaincy be a burden on a blossoming career?

Jared Rivers

Melbourne's most important player and key backman. Never been spoken about as leadership material which begs the question why? He is a gun of the competition, doesn't hit the back pages for the wrong reasons and has the respect of his teammates.

The darkhorse:


Cale Morton

Would Melbourne have the balls to pick an 18-year-old first year player as their next captain? Stranger things have happened and the skinny kid has excelled in his five games so far this year. A definite roughie, but may come into considerations later on if the Demons choose an older player to replace the inspirational Neitz.

For what it's worth, I think the Demons will play the conservative hand and choose co-captains, most probably Bruce and McDonald.

Who would I like to captain the side though? Easy. There is only one truly natural leader at Melbourne and it is Brock McLean, and, despite his misdemeanors, choosing an aggressive, straight-shooting hardman is exactly what the Dees need to lead them out of the doldrums.
112
Vote
   


TASMANIA'S push to get into the AFL got me thinking. Not whether the Apple Isle deserved its own team, or whether the AFL would ever take their push seriously but something more homogenous.

Would Tasmanian AFL supporters, who barrack with as much passion as anyone for their particular teams, switch allegiances if their state finally had a standalone team in the AFL


[ Click here to read more ]
99
Vote
   


AFL report cards - five weeks in

April 21st 2008 04:42
YES I know, it’s still early in the season but I decided it was time to look at how the AFL was shaping up for 2008.

Some may say it is too early to gauge how far teams have come in 08 but sometimes a month is enough – last year, six of the teams in the top 8 after four rounds played finals (Brisbane and Essendon dropped out for Collingwood and North Melbourne


[ Click here to read more ]
81
Vote
   


Real footy

April 21st 2008 04:29
JUST the other day I watched a game of bush football and remembered why I love the game.

Loaded up with the paper, the record, a radio to listen to my beloved Demons playing on the big stage at the G, I saw 46 people playing the game as it should be


[ Click here to read more ]
81
Vote
   


 

Recent Comments

I've not commented on anything yet :(