Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | Paid | My Orble | Login

The Voices in my Head - by The Voices in my Head

 
"Yet I find, yet I find repeating in my head...if I can't be my own...I'd feel better dead." Nutshell, Alice in Chains

My Apologies...

November 26th 2006 01:24
I was thinking earlier today about how much I miss Orble. Yes, I am here everyday. But I do not miss Orble as it is today...Orble as it was just a few weeks ago, where pleasant comments flowed and support bloomed and writing prevailed. When inflammatory or seductive pictures didn't make the post popular but the writing...I miss it.

I have been guilty of leaving some pretty heated comments lately. Adrian's philosophy blog has pushed a great deal of buttons with me but not because of his writing, which is brilliant, but because of my own personal issues regarding some of the topics he has posted for discussion.






I have had my feelings hurt over some comments that were left regarding a friend of mine and should have thought to consider the feelings which inspired the comments rather than the comments themselves, knowing the author of the comments.

I have been overwhelmed and stressed over the holidays and the numerous battles going on in my life and I have not been on my best behavior. I apologize to anyone I may have offended or hurt with any of the comments I have left. I am a passionate woman with opinions on everything. Truly, I apologize for any offense...(but not the stand I took...just the manner of it...)

I just hope that Orble can return to pleasantry, poetry, fantasies, thoughts and written words...

What is your opinion of Orble today? Do you feel it has changed? If so, how and what caused it? I know that I am not the only one to believe there is tension in the air. I have read several comments of others that have indicated I am not alone in this sadness. What, if anything, could happen to change this trend?
221
Vote


   
subscribe to this blog 


   

   

Thank you for stopping by to visit~ Remember to subscribe to this blog at the bottom of the page and to check out my domain blog, Muzikal Mafia.
~Do come back~



Comments
48 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by Adrienne

November 26th 2006 05:17
Aww, cheer up

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 05:30
Adrienne,
Oh, I will...*smile* I do wish for these things but as with all things in life, you just have to roll with the changes...Thank you. You are always a bright spot...

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by DuskDevi

November 26th 2006 07:34
Voices my Lady...

You are a wondrous being but you are human, as are we all. Although I admire and respect this post, please don't be so harsh on yourself.
I too have felt the change and have had to remove myself.
This post is a start at changing the trend.
Once we all understand that uniqueness is an individual right not a selective trait, we'll go beyond what is happening now...we can't go back but we'll get to a better place.

You are beautiful and brilliant and funny and compassionate and that is all I need from you.

Sending my affection to you Voices...

Devi

Comment by Brenton

November 26th 2006 08:33
I think it's that tripped out stressed out time of year.

And if you don't engage with issues, you never learn a damn thing, so no probs there.

And we're all guilty of the same, so be chilled.

Comment by Justin

November 26th 2006 09:30
Something has changed over the past few weeks. Perhaps it's to do with Orble offering people to buy out their domain blogs (for $95) due to people leaving or just the start of the silly season.
And what's with Homer having a restricted site!? That's bullshit. Why's he going elitist when before seemed so much the extraordinary everyday man. Shame.

Comment by Joe Blogg

November 26th 2006 10:11
If you don't mind me asking, being new here, what has actually changed?

And why is Orble offering to buy out domain blogs?

Comment by Justin

November 26th 2006 10:47
Not sure if you're referring to me specifically or anyone adopting the view generallu. But anyway, between a few months ago to just a couple of weeks, the Orble community has reportedly disintegrated.
It might possibly be the recent dissolution of a popular crowd that cheered each other and secularised others. Or it might be a downturn in writers productivity.
Or, it may just be over-sensitive fancies of the days of yore. I'm not sure.

Orble has recently offered the chance of domain blog owners to buy out the site they write on (so the writer owns all of the material s/he writes) from the frustration of getting a domain site for would-be writers, to find out shortly after they don't want it anymore, causing the Orble parties grief and resentment of the hassle of setting it up in the first place.

Comment by Damo

November 26th 2006 10:56
Personally I think that the power of the written word is overated.

To disagree is not the same as having a fight. Orble is a forum and a business. Like all businesses they want to make money. Here it is through sales of advertising space. And what sells the most advertising space?
Popularity. And what makes something popular to the broadest audience? Controversy.

The cosmetic changes on the look of orble confuse me and make it hard to track the writers I want to read. Also the number of Bloggers seems to have doubled in recents days.

Don't take this as being direct at you or anyone else but if something is pushing your buttons is it the words or the opinions that are disturbing? Agreeing to disagree is just a noble as winning someone over to your side.


Comment by Luke

November 26th 2006 11:03
I've been here since April and I think I can safely say that Orble is always changing and I don't think there is a really an 'ideal' Orble of 'yesterday' yet.

Soon there will be 1000 blogs on Orble. Isn't that scary?

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 15:05
Devi,
Thank you for your words. I appreciate them so much. Thank you for commenting...as always, you- all that I strive to be...

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 15:12
Brenton,
Don't even get me started on this time of the year! It's just horrible...but I will definitely blame some of my harsher remarks on that...*smile*

Thank you for commenting.

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 15:18
Justin,
The tension started way before the domain blog purchasing program, or at least I felt it before then...

As for Homer, I didn't know he restricted his site until this morning. I can't tell you what's going on...your guess is as good as mine. If you find out, will you let me know?

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 15:25
Joe Blog,
Just a few weeks ago, Orble was a sanctuary for writers. The posts were substantial and eloquent. It was supportive and the focus was on writing, not just pushing people's buttons for the sake of doing it or to be on the popular list. The desire for votes and popularity are fine but when it takes over your writing, it's not a good thing...

As for the domain blogs, they aren't buying them out. They are offering new bloggers the chance to buy a domains themselves because so many people are agreeing to a domain, which Orble pays for, and then quitting soon after.

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 15:32
Justin,
Do you really think that there was one group that was secularizing other writers? I don't think I agree with that...but I'm not sure...let me work this out.

I know that there were people, and still are, whose writing I simply admire greatly and I find new ones all the time. So, yes, I do tend to visit their sites as much as I can because I so enjoy their writing and time constraints do prevent me from checking out very many other sites at a time. However, it isn't about visiting those writers and not others so that we can cluster our votes...

No. I disagree or at least remove myself of all blame...I have not been guilty of this. *smile*

Actually, tell me more about this, Justin...why do you feel this way? And others out there, IS this the problem? Is this how you feel about the issue?

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by Wendi

November 26th 2006 15:33
One post on one blog struck me the wrong way and I've backed off a bit. For me, it's not about the votes, the cash, or the popularity. I began a blog for healing purposes, to explore my own interests further and record progress, and then a second to face my own issues about writing and why it's become a difficult "task" for me instead of the joy it used to be. In the mean time, I ran into people like you, Lilla, and a few other souls with whom I felt a connect.

I know what you mean about the time of year. I've been dealing with my own chaos as well.

As for the rest of what's going on with orble, I'm afraid I'm a bit lost. I haven't been very active this last week, so I'm in the dark.

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 15:43
Damo,

I do like the new homepage better than before and I love the search option, which helps me track a post I have left a comment on without the need for those pesky email reminders everyime someone leaves a comment. I hate the new logo though. I don't know about anyone else but I am not reporting anything...I'm writing.

As for what has been pushing my buttons, I reacted from a purely emotional standpoint due to my own experiences. I just need to turn it around and use it for inspiration, I think. Buckminster Fuller once said, "Don't fight forces, use them." *smile*

Thank you for commenting and do come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 15:47
Luke,
When I started Orble in early October...there were just under 750 blogs, if I remember correctly. Now, they are nearing 1000. That is significant growth...I just hope that Orble can keep up with it all.

I wasn't saying that it was ideal a few weeks ago but there did seem to be an intimacy that is disentigrating.

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 15:52
Wendi,
I do hope it wasn't mine!

I do not do this for votes either, but I do, do it for feedback, -(which comes with votes.) I am trying to find my voice, what works for me as a writer and the feedback in the Orble community is far superior to other sites.

I have missed you, Wendi!
Come back,
Voices~

Comment by Wendi

November 26th 2006 16:15
No, it wasn't yours - it was about how we are expected to "pay our dues" by commenting (even if on shallow or negative terms) on other people's blogs. It didn't set right with me.

Yet, it attempting to catch up this morning, I see a post titled "Why Pagans Should be Crucified" - The title alone infuriated me, and then I realized the post was from someone I had respected (which saddened me), but that the blog has been locked down, which frustrated me.

From there, I click to see the bare bottoms of abused children and it sickens me.

Suddenly, this isn't looking like the community I thought it was when I joined. It's disheartening.

I'm not throwing in the towel quite yet. I still enjoy your blogs, and Lilla's, and a few others... but the feelings I'm getting from Orble in general are discomforting and I'm re-evaluating my position in such a place.

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 16:27
Wendi,
I know. I really think it all started for me when the post about Britney Spears was at the top of the list for so damn long, the fact that that post stayed as high as it did for so long, speaks volumes. I mean, it was such a rediculous notion that anyone would find that worth clicking on, not because of the author...but because of the topic. That is when I began to think..."oh no". And then, enter pictures being displayed on the home page. Then writing took a back seat to publishing the most inflammatory pictures or misleading pictures one could find.

Please do not flit off into the night seeking a new fairyland...stay here and bring joy to this one...as you always do.

Come back,
Voices~

PS: The pagans being crucified post was not really about crucifying pagans but about writing such inflammatory titles or misleading titles to bring in the votes. Although, I should not speak for Homer. He prefers at this point not to speak for himself.

Comment by Wendi

November 26th 2006 16:42
Ah, well, that does make a difference now, doesn't it? And Homer is the KING of well-crafted titles that ARE usually appropriate to his posts... his titles are often what drew me and I was always delighted to see how his titles represented his writings. Glad to know it wasn't an all out bashing on a specific group. It really does make me feel better to know he was making a point. But, sad to see him locked away. I have no idea what spawned that, but it's all of our loss.

I suppose this is the problem with a small starter company growing and expanding. In the initial phases, a tight network is formed by those testing the waters, then a few serious people join the group and fuel the fire in a positive way. But eventually, everyone wanders in to see what the buzz is all about and you end up with what exists in the here and now - chaos, back stabbing, all-out attacks, temper tantrums, and vulgarity. I don't suppose that could be avoided, really.

I'm not sure if orble was ever intended for professional writers. You certainly don't have to be a professional, or even good at it, in order to keep a blog or share your opinions - and with blogs being the best thing since sliced bread in the world of the Internet, it's not surprising that everyone wants to capitalize on that. Orble is getting what it wanted out of the deal... good statistics for page views and click throughs. Whether or not we all get along is irrelivent - and sadly, the drama and controversy often over-ride or out-rank legitimate talent.

My blog isn't overwhelmingly popular, and that's just fine with me. My subject matter is not one everyone will embrace or delve into, but it works for me and that's why I do it. I actually enjoy reading and interacting with others as much as, if not more than I write in my own.

I'm learning that I just have to ignore those posts I find offensive - commenting only adds to their popularity and increases their ratings, so to comment is to cut off one's nose to spite their face. Some posts just aren't worth the vote - I can rant in other more productive ways.

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 26th 2006 16:47
Wendi,
I love that you said all of that about not commenting. I have decided to do the same. As much as I want to explain my take...I have to know that to do so, just adds fuel to the fire, in a negative way.

As for Homer, I prefer to comment on that by not commenting in a public forum. PM on the way.

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by Wendi

November 26th 2006 16:48
Oh, and speaking of rants... *smirk*

I won't do it, but my idea is this: In regard to the spankings post, a "clever" way to respond would be to not reply on the author's blog, but instead, make a post of your own called "Spank This" (or some other clever and catchy title) and have your rant. *LOL* - Why give the author feedback when you could intitiate feedback of your own? Shoot, it could ignite an all out "battle of the blogs" *LMAO*

Comment by Nina

November 26th 2006 21:42
I haven't noticed a huge amount of tension, but then I do tend to be a bit obtuse about these things. There have been a few posts that I've found confronting or irksome, but it's in my nature to let them pass by the wayside. However, that attitude is not necessarily a good one to have because it means I'm generally not proactive in fighting negative change...

I'm curious though, since you mentioned the KFed post (I believe I know which blog it was from), what issue exactly did you take with that? I was wondering because I am a frequenter of said blog, which always has amusing commentary on the shallowness of celebrity. I should note that the popularity of that post was mostly due to an ongoing 'comment conversation' between two people; the remaining comments were composed mostly of sarcastic remarks about the news.
What I guess it comes down to for me is that, no matter the subject matter, a post can have worth - if everything was deep and meaningful, my head would explode.

I hope I haven't offended you, it certainly wasn't my intention. I enjoy your writing and try to make it over as often as I can. I just felt that I should stick up for those of us whose writing delves into the more superficial. I believe any problems lie with posters who use misleading. controversial or confrontationary means to drive traffic to their site.


Comment by KylieW

November 26th 2006 23:01
Voices,

I think that it is important to remember that Orble is now a community of almost 1000 different people from different walks of life with different perspectives and interests. Some are beautifully written and in-depth posts (and I include yours in that) while others are just for fun or for shock value, and I actually find most of them fun or interesting. I love that I can go from one of Homers beautifully crafted poems, to reading about a 21 year old's 4 day drinking bender, and then go somewhere else and find out what is happening in the world of tv. I enjoy these blogs equally.....but for very different reasons.

In fact, of all the things I've read over the last months the ones that get me the most worked up are the ones suggesting that we 'have' to visit and comment on sites. I'm not here for the money, or popularity, but rather to hone my writing skills and find my voice (no pun intended). It's only been in recent weeks that my posts have started to make their way onto the popular lists, I hope because I've built up some regular readers who like my take on my chosen topic.

In fact, the K-Fed and Britney posts referred to in the comments above that spent so long in the popular sites were both mine. Fear not, I take no offense to your comments, as I know that you don't mean any offense to me personnally by them, and I can understand where you are coming from. I am sometimes surprised by the popularity of celebrity stories.....though I'm not sure why I am. Women's magazine's have enormous circulation and people like to read fun 'puff' pieces that don't challenge them sometimes. There's nothing wrong with that.

(Also, on a side note, some of those posts were very popular just because I was chatting to someone via the comments, not realising that the popularity of the post was going through the roof. Once I realised that I stopped doing that.....it's a bit unfair on everyone else).

With so many of us here, worlds are bound to collide and tension is inevitable. However, I really do believe that as everyone finds their place within this community an equilibrium will establish itself. Every time there is large growth, there must also be a period of adjustment.

But chin up, I think that these are teething problems due to such a lot of growth in a short amount of time, and that eventually an equilibrium will establish itself. So please hang in there. We would miss you too much if you were to get too frustrated and leave.

We all need to be patient and tolerant in the short term (yes I know, much easier said than done eh').

Also - one last thing to the lovely Nina. Thank you so much for your kind words about my take on my blog. That means a lot.

Lordy, I've written a novel rather than a comment! *sorry*

KylieW


Comment by Cibbuano

November 26th 2006 23:22
I think you'll find that the community will constantly shift and change... some people will like it, some people won't...

I'm still always pleased with the quality of writing on Orble, though!


Comment by MattH

November 26th 2006 23:59
change is the only constant in the universe.

Comment by Adrian

November 27th 2006 00:15
Hey Voices,

And I apologize for provoking you and dredging up unwanted memories. I never intended to cause you distress.

I think you're quite right not to apologize for the stands you take. Freedom of individual conscience should be absolute.

And if you feel passionately about an issue, no one can blame you for expressing that.

On the matter of Orble community change, I'd agree with whoever said that Orble has been changing continuously since its inception, and that there hasn't been a golden age.

1000 blogs today, but it's only recently that Jon has opened up the floodgates. At the same rate of growth, 10,000 could comfortably be reached by this time next year -- but presumably rate of growth will increase.

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 00:25
Wendi,
You are a spitfire, aren't you? *smile* If my husband ever cheats on me, I am calling you.

Thank you for commenting, as always,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 00:30
Nina,
Thank you for that insight. I hadn't considered that aspect and I concede to you on that one. How absolutely right you are that it would be a dreary place if there were nothing to laugh at. Some of us find humor in celebrity news while I found a lot of humor in one of Adrian's posts, that a lot of people didn't. (I refer you to 'About Skinning Your Husband and Cooking His Head...' on Adrian's Philosophy Blog. It's morbidly disturbing but I laughed...not everyone is entertained by the same things.

Thank you for coming by,
Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 00:36
KylieW,
Several things I want to address:

First, thank you for taking that remark in the spirit it was intended. That was gracious of you.

Second, As for how it remained on the popular list, that is not necessary to explain here. I am glad that you are here and doing exactly what you do. Nina certainly provided some clarity on the issue. But each of us, regardless of what we write about, should feel comfortable doing exactly that.

Third, as for being patient...this is NOT one of my strong suits. I don't like change and I honestly felt I had walked into a dream world here at Orble. Such depth and skill...it was heaven and I have learned a tremendous amount about writing from everyone here. The selfish part of me was very afraid that was all about to end!

Fourth, thank you again for your comment...I really appreciated it.

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 00:38
Cibby,
I agree that it will always change and I agree that some people won't like it. *smile*

I don't care for change much..it's a fault of mine. But I have apologized enough today for my faults! lol

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 00:39
Matt H,
True. I don't have to like it though. *smile*

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by Wendi

November 27th 2006 00:39
Voices - I've been called worse. *giggles*

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 00:43
Adrian,
No need for you to apologize for anything at all. Well...maybe one thing...the title to that one post..you know which one..about cooking...it was too funny! I went into the post already laughing. How could I possibly take it seriously after that?

You might be interested to know that the majority of my Thanksgiving dinner was spent telling everyone about it. My family also found it hilarious. See? Another reason I can't help finding it funny...it's in my gene pool.

*smile*
Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 00:45
Wendi,
Join the club, sweetie...join the club.

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by Justin

November 27th 2006 02:13
Hey Voices,

My comment obviously struck a chord on some level as you replied to it twice! Don't know if that was intentional or not but anyway, I'll try to elaborate on my opinion.

What I meant was that Orble was becoming subject to politicisation, if that's even a word. Certain members were bolstering each others endeavours on posting by forming a type of clique that supported each other overwhelmingly. In turn, this created a us and them dichotomy of those who were in the group and those who weren't. Or a type of secularisation of communities within Orble, developed by one group having separate (or additional) ideas on what constituted good Orble posting and the way things should be or liked to be.

The recent objection to others posts not within the party and a feeling of distress felt by those within the party had expressed explains a shift that didn't unite all others voices into the parties secularised beliefs or interests. To put it bluntly, a sub-community within Orble was straying away from the larger, independent community yet the sub-community wanted to become the dominant power or culture.

Notably, most of the clash came from Adrian's posts which delved outside the boundaries of accepted norms the sub-community had developed, yet their feeling to the sub-community was strained owing to their loyalty to the group and their individual interests.

It's all very implicit and understated, but that's what I think happened. To assure everyone, I'm not pro or anti any group, merely explaining some events that I think attribute largely to the feeling of unwellness or waywardness some feel Orble has drifted to.

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 02:20
Justin,
You posted twice, so I responded separately because I just respond in order of comments...if that makes sense to you.

Well, you are analytical, aren't you? lol

I don't believe there is a subgroup of any kind and I don't believe that anyone is seeking dominance in the way you have described. Everyone, okay, nearly everyone who posts wants their blog to do well, and if their blog has become a domain, they definitely want it to do well, so dominance of that nature, yes, I will agree with.

If there are any groups out there that are trying to take over the world of Orble...I stand firm against it! I am not for global domination, at all. *smile*

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by Vixter

November 27th 2006 03:01
Maybe I don't get that involved to notice the dramatic shifts, but I do know that the posts that are popular are as you say, the colourful ones.

I notice also that the people who are dominating tend to change they go then come back....if that makes anysense.

I have never been that popular myself so i don't know where the differences are there either.

Do you still enjoy writing at least?


Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 03:27
Vixter,
One thing that I will always enjoy doing, regardless, is writing. It is a passion and a drive that I will always have.

I haven't been at Orble very long. It is more than likely my own misperceptions that have caused me to feel this way, but Orble felt much different to me in October, when I joined than it does today.

As I mentioned to Justin, I do not really think there are a group of people out there in Orbleland that want to dominate for the sake of control. What would they control anyways? *smile* I do think there are some very powerful personalities that come across and light up a 'room' with their comments. Perhaps that is being taken as dominance.

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by LaurenD

November 27th 2006 06:02
I agree with you on this, Voices, and I've been on the fence myself.

I don't like some of the tactics people use to get points around here. I'm a serious writer, and I've never been that tactical. Maybe that's considered a problem by some, when I see it as integrity.

Ah well.

I'm going to hang in there for a bit longer and see how things turn. There are some good people mixing here, even if there are a few potato heads.

LaurenD

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 09:31
LaurenD,
Thanks, friend. I know that things can improve, even if there are a lot of people joining everyday. I think, too, that there have been some inflammatory posts lately that insinuate there is a blogging etiquette that may be leading to some tensions too. Several people have mentioned this to me in their comments.

No one should ever feel like they have to leave a comment just because someone leaves a comment on your post, in my mind. I would much rather someone come and comment because something strikes resonates with them than to have people come and leave comments just for the sake of doing it.

I say the new Orble motto should be:

Live, Let Live and Let Love Rule


(I am on SUCH a Lenny Kravitz kick right now...lol)

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by LaurenD

November 27th 2006 09:45
Nice. Rock on, Voices.

LaurenD

Comment by Judy

November 27th 2006 11:22
Voices, You shouldn't worry too much about the changes on Orble. Blogging is a hobby and shouldn't be taken too seriously. Just enjoy writing and reading your fave blogs!!

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 12:31
LaurenD,
Backatcha!

Come back,
Voices~

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 27th 2006 12:33
Judy,
Writing is my passion and nothing could sway me from that. The changes or tensions, whichever they are, that are occurring right now don't take away from that. I do miss certain aspects that haven't been here as of late...but thank you for your comments!

Come back,
Voices

Comment by Bryn

November 27th 2006 23:15
Rock'n'roll.
Deal with it.
Life's a ballad.
Love's a disco groove.
Laughter's like a Stairway to Heaven.

Comment by The Voices in my Head

November 28th 2006 03:34
Bryn,
Play that funky music, bad boy...Live, Let Live and Let Love Rule, I say! It is going to be my new motto...rather than come back. All Hail, Lenny Kravitz...

*smile*
Live, Let Live and Let Love Rule,
Voices~

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
1 Posts
1 Posts
1 Posts
88 Posts dating from October 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

The Voices in my Head's Blogs

I have no other blogs :(
Copyright © 2012 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]