Why Disney's Up Almost Brings Us Down
June 10th 2009 02:22
Disney's Up, which is currently playing in theaters, almost brings us viewers down. In the first few moments of the film, I found myself being easily captivated by the pleasant colors, images, and sounds that accompanied my initial meeting of the main character, Carl Frederickson, a boy who idolizes a famous pilot and aspires to fly like he does. On his way home one day, he sees and enters an abandoned house, where he meets Elllie, a tomboy who shares his passion and who will eventually become his wife. What follows next is a quick succession of scenes without dialogue: their courtship and marriage, their work at a zoo, Ellie's pregnancy woes, and eventual death. We are left, then, with a curmudgeonous 78 year old version of Carl to take us through the remaining 60 minutes of the film. It was heavy. Maybe not for my 3 year old, but for me, at least. Even the ending of the film, in which Mr. Frederickson accompanies Russell, his boy scout sidekick in his adventures through South America in a house propelled by helium balloons, to the award ceremony where Russell receives his badge for helping the elderly is weighty and emotional because Russell's dad is absent. I realize Bambi's mother dies at the beginning of that classic and that the step-mother in Cinderella and the evil queen in Snow White are far from pleasant. But this film's depiction of miscarriage, aging, and mortality is not cloaked in fairytale film conventions. Don't let the pixillation fool you; this is more a film for adults that kids can enjoy than a film for kids that adults can enjoy. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the film. It's worth seeing. But it is for those who want a good dose of reality in slightly more palatable form than say the newspaper or cable TV, not for those who want to escape from it.
| 43 |
| Vote |

Add Comments



